Discerning God’s Will

A reader asks:

What are some clear signs when discerning a decision?

We have a life decision as a family to make and we’ve been searching for an answer for the better part of 4 years with no clear signs. It feels as though we are living in some kind of limbo waiting for some kind of sign from God. We are restless and uneasy with the situation we currently have. I’ve always thought that when you’re making the right decision in Gods perfect time, that doors will be opened, the right people will be put in your path etc. And when it’s not the right time doors will be slammed in your face and no matter how much you fight, you won’t get anywhere. Is that accurate? Or will there be situations where you’re forced to tear down doors and try to make the impossible, possible?

1. Discerning God’s Will Is Not Passive—It Requires Action and Peace

There’s a common mistake in our circles: waiting passively for a “sign from Heaven” while the roof leaks and the kids are growing. God’s will is not usually revealed in fireworks or prophetic dreams. More often, it’s revealed through ordered desire, peace, circumstances, and moral clarity.

As St. Ignatius of Loyola put it: “God’s will is known through consolation and desolation.” That is:

  • When you imagine walking through a certain door, do you experience peace—even if it’s scary or sacrificial?
  • When you cling to the status quo, is it true peace, or is it avoidance, fear, or despair?

Restlessness is a sign. Not always that something is wrong morally, but that something is incomplete. God stirs the heart to prevent us from settling into false peace.


2. Doors Opening and Closing: Truth or Myth?

You’re right in thinking that God will sometimes open doors when it’s His time. But here’s the critical part:

Sometimes God leaves the door closed to see if you’re willing to knock hard enough to prove your faith and leadership.

That’s not contradiction—it’s Scripture:

“Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you.” (Matt 7:7)

He doesn’t say, “Wait by the door until I open it.” He says knock. That’s action. That’s faith.

In some seasons, you will have to tear down a door, as you said—but only when you’re sure it’s the right house.

So, is it accurate to believe:

  • Open doors mean “go”? ✅ Yes, often.
  • Closed doors mean “stop”? ⚠️ Not always.
  • Sometimes God waits for you to lead in faith and knock? ✅ Absolutely.

3. Four Marks of a God-Guided Decision

Here’s a framework you can use to test if it’s time to move:

1. Is it morally sound?

This is non-negotiable. Is the decision consistent with the teachings of the Church, your duties as a husband and father, and your role as protector and provider?

If yes, proceed.

2. Does it bring greater order to your family?

God’s will always moves us toward order, not chaos. Even if it’s difficult or sacrificial, will this decision:

  • Strengthen your marriage?
  • Provide a more stable environment for your children?
  • Allow you to fulfill your God-given vocation more fully?

If yes, that’s a green light.

3. Is there peace in your heart?

Not the peace of comfort—but the peace of conviction. The kind you feel before stepping onto a battlefield because it’s the right fight.

If your heart is restless from avoidance, it’s time to move.

4. Are you staying put out of fear?

Fear is not from God. Prudence is from God. But fear that paralyzes the will is the devil’s tool. Satan doesn’t need you to commit mortal sin—he just needs you stuck.

If fear is holding you back, it’s time to fast, pray, and then act.


4. What Would You Advise Your Own Son If He Were in Your Shoes?

This is a sobering question I ask myself often. If my grown son came to me with this same dilemma, what would I tell him?

That’s your mirror. That’s your clarity.

If you would tell your son, “Son, it’s time to make a move. It’s been long enough. Trust God and lead your family,” then there’s your answer.


5. Final Thoughts: God Trusts You to Lead

God gave you the authority in your home. You don’t need a neon sign from Heaven. You need prayer, prudence, and boldness. If you’ve been faithful in prayer, you’ve already been given more than most.

So here’s the challenge:

  • Stop waiting for peace to fall on you like a blanket. Peace follows obedience.
  • Make the best decision you can with what you have. God will guide your steps once you start moving.
  • And if a door slams hard? You’ll know it’s not the one. But don’t wait for it to open magically.

God doesn’t guide parked cars. Start driving—He’ll steer.

The Conclave No One Is Talking About – Welcome to Tradition with Charles Fraune – Episode 48

We discuss the 1775 Papal Conclave, focusing on St. Alphonsus Liguori’s significant role and the political factions influencing the election of Pope Pius VI. We discuss the conclave’s length, the challenges faced, and the parallels to the contemporary Church, concluding with a call for listeners to prioritize personal holiness through prayer and spiritual practices. More about Charles Fraune here:

The Truth About the Pagan Origins of Catholicism – Welcome to Tradition Episode 46

Jim de Piante is back and has a lot to say, including: -Why he thinks it’s a good thing the Nativity is celebrated on Dec 25 (Sol Invictus/Winter Equinox) -The pagan origins of priests, virgins and sacrificial rituals -Whether it’s okay to burn Hindu incense in your home

Will Sister Wilhemina’s Body Really Save the World? Louis Tofari joins WtT – Episode 33

Some Catholics-even traditionalists-are proclaiming a miracle and alleging Sister Wilhemina Lancaster’s body is incorrupt. But is that true? And how has the Church traditionally responded to claims of miracles?

In this episode, Louis Tofari covers some important topics: -The process for evaluating claims of a miracle -The role of the local ordinary -The shocking pollution of the body and grounds by thousands of visitors -The possible motives for the disregard of Church laws and traditions in this situation And of course, much more. Join us for a sober but important discussion about Catholic customs, traditions and laws.

Ember Days with Louis Tofari; WtT-Ep 19

In this fascinating discussion, guest Louis Tofari covers a wide range of topics, including: -Ember Days -The origin of the-Gregorian Calendar -The truth about Galileo -Rogations -Sola Scriptura -Justification -Predestination -The Catholic origins of Tempura And even why you should eat pork on St Mark’s Feast Day. It’s a long one but a great one! Be sure to visit Louis at RomanitasPress.com

Welcome to Tradition – Episode 14 – Gregory DiPippo and the 1955 Holy Week Reforms

In this episode, you’ll hear Gregory DiPippo explain why he believes the 1955 reforms to the Holy Week liturgies formed the groundwork for the Novus Ordo reforms that would come 14 years later. We talked about: -The major changes to the liturgy -Anibale Bugnini’s role -Archbishop Lefebvre’s decision to accept the 1955 reforms -The leading role sedevacantists have played in opposing the 1955 reforms And of course, much more. If you want to learn about liturgy, join us!

Louis Tofari and 1955 Holy Week Reform (Part 2); WtT-Ep 10

This is part two of my interview with Louis Tofari about the changes to the Holy Week liturgy in 1955. Part one was surprisingly controversial with some members of the audience. In today’s episode, you’ll learn: -The false accusations by some trads against holy popes Pius X and Pius XII -Who was Bugnini and was he involved in the 1955 reforms? -The evidence that Bugnini was ‘turned’ by the Masons in 1963 -Itemization of how Holy Week reform is actually an improvement from the pre-55 -What ‘active participation’ really means And of course, much more in this hour-long conversation with Louis Tofari of Romanitas Press

Louis Tofari and 1955 Holy Week Reform (Part 1); WtT-Ep 9

This is part one of a two-part interview of Louis Tofari on the liturgy of Holy Week and the changes that were made under Pius XII in 1955. Here are a few of the things you’ll learn in this episode: -What is the Pope’s authority over liturgy? -Did reform of the liturgy start/stop at Trent? -What makes a liturgy ‘Roman’ -The surprising (sedevacantist) origins of opposition to the 1955 reforms -How many pre-55ers actually advocate for modernist-style approaches to liturgy and obedience -The neo-antiquarianism of many who oppose the 1955 reforms -How do we distinguish between pre-conciliar and post-conciliar liturgical changs? -What’s our standard for authentic obedience of the faithful? -Significant differences between Eastern and Western liturgies. Some relevant links: https://www.romanitaspress.com/liturg… https://sspx.org/en/only-when-faith-q… https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-x…